Dear
Mr. Owen,
The piping of
oil has a
history of
spills. Four
days ago,
aboriginal
land in
Sasketchewan,
Canada, was
polluted with
over 200,000
gallons of
oil. Two days
ago, the
Magellan
pipeline in
Worth county,
Iowa, spilled
138,000
gallons of oil
onto private
land. In
2017, there
were 29 oil
spills
according to
the Wikipedia
article on the
subject.
There may
have been
others not
listed in that
source.
Oil spills are a
disaster, and
when those
spills pollute
the water
sources for a
community, or
a series of
communities
along a major
river, they
become
inexcusable.
No company
has the right
to profit at
the cost of so
much
dislocation
and suffering
of innocent
citizens.
This is
especially
true for
people who
derive their
livelihoods in
some way or
other from the
polluted land
or water. The
Native
Americans who
are now
confined to
the
reservations
to be
transited by
the DAPL have
traditionally
used the
rivers there
for literally
millennia to
transport
their food
source, the
buffalo which
they hunt.
How will they
eat now if the
buffalo are
floated
downriver in
waters
contaminated
with oil?
Which brings up
the question
of treaty
rights.
Native
Americans were
confined by
treaty to the
most
unproductive
lands on the
continent.
Now, with oil
companies
threatening
their
territories,
where else are
they supposed
to go? Their
treaties
imposed solemn
obligations on
the US
government,
obligations
which almost
uniformly were
ignored.
This is a
national
disgrace.
I hope you will
deny
permission for
any oil
company to
build
pipelines on
native land
without the
free and
express
permission of
the tribe
which owns
that land.
Cordially,
Romi Elnagar,
natural-born
US citizen
Baton Rouge,
Louisiana